Jimmy Kimmel Live! host Jimmy Kimmel was visited by a pair of pretty famous guests during Tuesday night’s show (12/19).

Kimmel first spoke to God, who happened to look an awful lot like actor Billy Crystal. God was later joined by his ‘friend,’ Satan, who resembled Foo Fighters singer Dave Grohl.

This wouldn’t be the first time Grohl portrayed Satan. The singer also appeared as the devil in Tenacious D’s video for ‘Tribute,’ which you can see below.